Skip to main content

Answer

Prerequisites​

  • Bayes Decision Rule (BDR)
  • Absolute Loss Function (L1L_1 loss)
  • Conditional Risk
  • Leibniz Integral Rule
  • Definition of Median

Step-by-Step Derivation​

  1. Define the Conditional Risk for q=1q=1: For q=1q=1, the loss function is the absolute loss: L1(g(x),y)=∣g(x)−y∣L_1(g(x), y) = |g(x) - y|. The conditional risk is: R(x)=∫−∞∞∣g(x)−y∣p(y∣x)dyR(x) = \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} |g(x) - y| p(y|x) dy

  2. Split the Integral: To handle the absolute value, we split the integral at y=g(x)y = g(x): R(x)=∫−∞g(x)(g(x)−y)p(y∣x)dy+∫g(x)∞(y−g(x))p(y∣x)dyR(x) = \int_{-\infty}^{g(x)} (g(x) - y) p(y|x) dy + \int_{g(x)}^{\infty} (y - g(x)) p(y|x) dy

  3. Minimize the Conditional Risk: We take the derivative of R(x)R(x) with respect to g(x)g(x) and set it to zero. We use the Leibniz integral rule, which states: ddz∫a(z)b(z)f(y,z)dy=f(b(z),z)⋅b′(z)−f(a(z),z)⋅a′(z)+∫a(z)b(z)∂f(y,z)∂zdy\frac{d}{dz} \int_{a(z)}^{b(z)} f(y, z) dy = f(b(z), z) \cdot b'(z) - f(a(z), z) \cdot a'(z) + \int_{a(z)}^{b(z)} \frac{\partial f(y, z)}{\partial z} dy

    Applying this to our risk function (letting g(x)g(x) be the variable we differentiate with respect to): ∂R(x)∂g(x)=∂∂g(x)[∫−∞g(x)(g(x)−y)p(y∣x)dy]+∂∂g(x)[∫g(x)∞(y−g(x))p(y∣x)dy]\frac{\partial R(x)}{\partial g(x)} = \frac{\partial}{\partial g(x)} \left[ \int_{-\infty}^{g(x)} (g(x) - y) p(y|x) dy \right] + \frac{\partial}{\partial g(x)} \left[ \int_{g(x)}^{\infty} (y - g(x)) p(y|x) dy \right]

    First term: (g(x)−g(x))p(g(x)∣x)⋅1−0+∫−∞g(x)1⋅p(y∣x)dy=∫−∞g(x)p(y∣x)dy(g(x) - g(x))p(g(x)|x) \cdot 1 - 0 + \int_{-\infty}^{g(x)} 1 \cdot p(y|x) dy = \int_{-\infty}^{g(x)} p(y|x) dy

    Second term: 0−(g(x)−g(x))p(g(x)∣x)⋅1+∫g(x)∞(−1)⋅p(y∣x)dy=−∫g(x)∞p(y∣x)dy0 - (g(x) - g(x))p(g(x)|x) \cdot 1 + \int_{g(x)}^{\infty} (-1) \cdot p(y|x) dy = -\int_{g(x)}^{\infty} p(y|x) dy

    Combining them: ∂R(x)∂g(x)=∫−∞g(x)p(y∣x)dy−∫g(x)∞p(y∣x)dy\frac{\partial R(x)}{\partial g(x)} = \int_{-\infty}^{g(x)} p(y|x) dy - \int_{g(x)}^{\infty} p(y|x) dy

  4. Set the Derivative to Zero: ∫−∞g∗(x)p(y∣x)dy−∫g∗(x)∞p(y∣x)dy=0\int_{-\infty}^{g^*(x)} p(y|x) dy - \int_{g^*(x)}^{\infty} p(y|x) dy = 0 ∫−∞g∗(x)p(y∣x)dy=∫g∗(x)∞p(y∣x)dy\int_{-\infty}^{g^*(x)} p(y|x) dy = \int_{g^*(x)}^{\infty} p(y|x) dy

  5. Interpret the Result: The equation states that the probability mass to the left of g∗(x)g^*(x) must equal the probability mass to the right of g∗(x)g^*(x). Since the total probability is 1, each side must equal 0.5: ∫−∞g∗(x)p(y∣x)dy=0.5\int_{-\infty}^{g^*(x)} p(y|x) dy = 0.5 This is the exact definition of the median of the conditional distribution p(y∣x)p(y|x). Therefore, g∗(x)=median(y∣x)g^*(x) = \text{median}(y|x).